Futility is resistant

  • 0 Posts
  • 3 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 19th, 2023

help-circle

  • When I said Adira is a nonbinary girl, I meant she is female of sex and nonbinary of chosen gender.

    it was a big deal when they announced her, but the treatment was milquetoast and timid. Same with the few non-cis characters, they were tokens, the show didn’t have the courage to depict a future where a diverse gender philosophy is widely accepted. They yellowed out of it and presented as if it was still our time. I don’t dislike the show for being woke, I dislike it for being shallow woke.

    Same with the rest of it, it was 90% SFX and 10% writing. With long series like TNG you can afford the luxury of experimenting and fumbling the ball some weeks, it Discovery and Picard and massive productions that only have 12 episodes a year. They had to make every one of those count.

    About Michael ‘s learned Vulcan powers, I don’t buy that. She was best than the Vulcans at their own academy, seemingly an expert at hand to hand combat, basically a prodigy at everything she wanted to do. That’s bad writing, super geniuses are too easy to write, so they had to make her emotionally immature to give her some challenge. Given she cried almost every episode, I’d seriously doubt she took to heart those meditation lessons.

    It is a very flashy but bad show overall. If it hadn’t carried the name of Star Trek, it might have carved a niche in Sci-Fi, though. Space novels were called Space Operas after all.


  • fans that hate it just because it’s different

    Fans hated it not solely because it was different, that’s hardly a reason. They hated it because:

    • For the first time, Starfleet officers were emotionally-stunted or plain assholes instead of well-adapted officers.
    • The series revolved around a divisive character, hoping I guess that some people would become hardcore fans of Michael.
    • It intentionally wrecked canon, even one of the producers proudly said he didn’t watch Star Trek to avoid preconceptions.
    • Tech doesn’t make sense for its time. Practically none of it made any sense for a prequel, maybe if it had been a sequel.
    • The forced linking of the main protagonist to Spock was unbelievable, more so because it somehow gave her Vulcan powers by osmosis.
    • It promoted itself as progressive, but all it did was including a gay couple and a non-binary girl. The important characters were all cis, or left unspoken.

    It wasn’t just different, it was bad. Really bad. It was like a vuvuzela in an acoustic song.

    And this is coming from someone who watched a season and a half before quitting, but who loved Enterprise, who also had its glaring flaws, but was true to canon.